Google Search Console: A Contractor's Guide to the Reports That Matter
Mission, Vision & Values

Awards and Partners
Google Partner Logo
PHCC Logo
QSC Logo
Service Roundtable
Nexstar Network Logo

Google Search Console is free, it is the only place Google tells you directly how it sees your website, and most contractors either never set it up or never open it. This guide covers the five things worth checking, what good looks like for a home service company, and the reports that predict a problem before your phone volume falls.

Watch the training: ROI reporting for contractors

How the numbers in Search Console connect to calls, booked jobs and cost per acquisition.

Set it up properly, once

  • Verify the domain property, not just the URL prefix. Domain verification (via a DNS record) covers every subdomain and both http and https, so you stop looking at a quarter of your data by accident.
  • Submit your XML sitemap and confirm it returns the page count you expect. A sitemap listing 40 pages on a 300-page site is a red flag on day one.
  • Connect it to Analytics and to your Google Business Profile insights so organic clicks, calls and booked jobs can be read side by side.
  • Add everyone who needs it — you, your marketing partner, your web developer. Access sitting with a former vendor is a problem you want to discover now, not during an outage.

Search Console only holds 16 months of data. If nobody has ever set it up, today is the earliest you will ever have a baseline — do it before you need it.

The five reports worth your time

1. Performance — what you actually rank for

Clicks, impressions, click-through rate and average position, by query and by page. Filter to the last three months and compare year over year, never month over month, because heating and cooling demand is seasonal.

What to look for: high-impression, low-click queries (you rank but nobody clicks — usually a weak title or a missing map pack presence), queries sitting at positions 5–15 (the cheapest wins available, because moving 8 to 4 is far easier than 40 to 4), and emergency or “near me” terms where you should be dominant.

2. Pages — what Google has and hasn't indexed

The Indexing report tells you which pages are in the index and why the rest are not. “Crawled — currently not indexed” on a batch of city pages is Google saying those pages are not worth including, which is a content quality verdict, not a bug. “Discovered — currently not indexed” across many pages usually points to crawl budget or thin templates.

3. Experience and Core Web Vitals

Real-world speed and stability data from actual visitors, split by mobile and desktop. For contractors, mobile is the number that matters — the majority of emergency searches happen on a phone, often on cellular. Slow mobile pages cost you calls long before they cost you rankings.

4. Enhancements

Where Google reports on your structured data — whether your schema markup is valid, and which pages have errors. This is also where you notice markup silently disappearing after a site update.

5. Manual Actions and Security

Check these twice a year and any time traffic falls sharply. They are almost always empty — which is exactly the point, because it rules out a penalty in ten seconds and lets you look for the real cause.

What good looks like for a contractor

  • Impressions trending up year over year on service and city queries, not just brand searches. Growth that is all branded means your reputation is working and your search visibility is not.
  • Your money terms in the top three — the service plus city combinations attached to real jobs, not vanity keywords.
  • Nearly all real pages indexed. A large gap between submitted and indexed pages means Google is declining to include your content.
  • Mobile Core Web Vitals in the green, or with a clear plan to get there.
  • No manual actions, no security issues, no coverage cliffs after site changes.

The monthly ten-minute routine

  1. Performance, last 28 days versus the same period last year — clicks and impressions.
  2. Top 20 queries: anything new, anything lost.
  3. Any position 5–15 query with real volume goes on the list for content work this month.
  4. Indexing report: any new errors since last month.
  5. Enhancements: any new structured data errors.

Ten minutes, monthly, catches almost everything that would otherwise turn into a quarter of lost lead flow. If you work with us, this is part of the reporting you receive — but you should still have your own access and know how to read it.

Questions we get asked

Why don't the numbers match Google Analytics?They measure different things. Search Console counts impressions and clicks from Google Search; Analytics counts sessions on your site from every source. They will never tie out exactly.
Does average position mean my ranking?It is an average across every query, device and location where you appeared — useful as a trend, misleading as an absolute. It also excludes the map pack entirely.
My marketing company has access. Do I need my own?Yes. It is your data and your domain. Verify a property yourself so you keep it regardless of who you work with.
Nothing is indexed. What now?Check for a noindex tag or a blocking robots.txt rule first — on new and rebuilt sites, a staging setting left switched on is by far the most common cause.
600+Contractors served
96.7%Client retention
15+ yrsHome services only
7.1MLeads converted

Not ready to talk? Read the book first.

Josh Nelson's How to Triple Your Sales by Getting Your Digital Marketing Right lays out this entire system, written for plumbing, HVAC and electrical contractors. Read it online, listen to the audiobook in the truck, or download the PDF.

It comes with the Growth Training Library: 10 recorded workshops, a keyword research tool, the Marketing Plan Builder, a Google Business Profile action plan and the lead-gap calculator. Delivered by email, instantly. No call required.

Get free access to the book and the Growth Training Library →

Schedule a Strategy Session

Bring your market and your numbers. We will show you where you stand against your real competitors, what is holding your visibility back, and what it would take to fix it — whether or not you hire us.

We work with one contractor per market.

Schedule a Strategy Session

Keep going

More frameworks in the contractor resource library, or see what this work produces in the contractor case studies.

96.7%

Client Retention

Our clients stay with us for years, not months.
600+

Contractors Served

Our clients span the US, Canada, and Australia.
7,121,650

Leads Converted

Great results speak for themselves.
Better results are here!

Get the Best Selling Book on Digital Marketing for Plumbing & HVAC Contractors FREE! (Just Cover SHIPPING!) Limited Time Offer!

Over 153 pages Of AMAZING info that will change the way you look at digital marketing! Based on real-world examples and case studies of other plumbing and HVAC contractors.

Schedule Strategy Session
Josh Nelson Co-Founder & CEO

Why Plumbing & HVAC SEO?

Over 300 Plumbing & HVAC companies served and 20,000 leads generated monthly.
Call Us 866-610-4647
Marketing Resources & Guides