Score Your AI Visibility: A 21-Point Scorecard and 90-Day Plan


Awards and Partners
Google Partner Logo
PHCC Logo
QSC Logo
Service Roundtable
Nexstar Network Logo

Knowing that AI engines are not recommending your company is only useful if it turns into a plan. In the Search Everywhere Optimization workshop, Josh Nelson had contractors score themselves on seven website pages, zero to three each, for a total out of 21.

Most started near zero. Here is the scorecard, and the ninety day rollout that moves it.

The Scorecard

Seven pages, scored zero to three each, for a maximum of 21. Zero means the page does not exist.
Three means it exists and it is genuinely good. One or two means you have something that gestures at
it but does not do the job.

The AI visibility scorecard from the Search Everywhere Optimization workshop
# Page Score 3 looks like
1 Pricing guide and price estimator Published ranges, the factors behind them, and an interactive estimator that captures the lead
2 Best of comparison page Top 10 to 25 companies in your market, stated criteria, honest notes, real links
3 Ultimate review hub Reviews pulled from every platform, totals by source, sentiment themes, updated regularly
4 Security, safety and privacy Plain English answers on background checks, insurance, property and data
5 Author and team pages Real people, real credentials, linked from all content
6 Awards and recognitions Each award explained and linked to its source
7 Mother of all FAQs One deep FAQ hub per service line, schema marked up

Score yourself honestly. In the live workshop, the most common first score was zero. One attendee
put it well: awareness precedes change.

Days 1 to 30: Baseline and the Two Money Pages

  • Week 1. Run the five prompt AI visibility test across ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity
    and Google AI mode. Log where you appear and which competitors keep showing up. Ask each engine why
    it chose its number one.
  • Week 2. Score the seven pages. Write the number down, because you will re-score
    in ninety days.
  • Weeks 3 and 4. Build the pricing guide. Ranges, not quotes, plus an honest
    explanation of what drives cost in your market. Then add a price estimator. A calculator that gives a
    range in exchange for a name, phone and email converts far better than a bare scheduling button,
    which is why it is the first thing to build.

Days 31 to 60: Comparison, Reviews and People

  • Week 5 and 6. Build the best of comparison page. Yes, you are listing
    competitors. They already appear when a customer searches your city plus your service, so you may as
    well be the company that publishes the most thorough, most honest comparison in the market. Set the
    criteria, go deep on the data, and make sure you are in the list.
  • Week 7. Build the review hub. Every platform you are on, totals and averages by
    source, what customers mention most, and the individual reviews themselves with dates.
  • Week 8. Build the author and team page and link it from every piece of content
    you publish.

The comparison page is the one contractors fight hardest. It is also the one that shows up as the source table inside AI overviews for best of searches in your city.

Days 61 to 90: Depth, Trust and Re-Score

  • Weeks 9 to 11. Build the FAQ hubs, one per service line. This is the biggest
    block of work and the biggest content surface for AI to quote.
  • Week 12. Add the awards page and the security, safety and privacy page.
  • Week 13. Re-run the five prompts, re-score the seven pages, and compare against
    your baseline. Then set the next ninety days.

Meanwhile the fundamentals keep running underneath all of it: a page for each city you serve,
unique title tags and H1s on every page, no copied content, fast load times you can verify in
PageSpeed Insights, HTTPS, an about page that tells the owner's story, guarantees, case studies and
testimonials. Check how long this work takes to show up in lead flow before you set
expectations with your team.

Who Does the Work

Every item on this list is something a contractor can do in house. Most will not, because the
season gets busy and the pricing page is nobody's emergency. If you want the assessment done for you,
we will run about 35 AI prompts across your top services and cities, build your keyword and ranking
analysis and show you where you stand: book a free strategy session.

The full workbook, the prompts and the scorecard are inside the Growth Training Library along with
the rest of our workshop series, free.

Get the Book and the Full Growth Training Library, Free

Josh Nelson's book, How to Triple Your Sales by Getting Your Digital Marketing Right, plus the complete Growth Training Library: 10 workshops covering local search, paid ads, website conversion and tracking, built specifically for plumbing, HVAC and electrical contractors. Read it, watch it, and put it to work in your own company.

Get Free Access Now

Already know you want help running it? Schedule a free strategy session.


96%+

Average Monthly Client Retention

600+

Contractors Served

Our clients span the US, Canada, and Australia.
7,121,650

Leads Converted

Great results speak for themselves.
Better results are here!

Get the Best Selling Book on Digital Marketing for Plumbing & HVAC Contractors FREE! (Just Cover SHIPPING!) Limited Time Offer!

Over 153 pages Of AMAZING info that will change the way you look at digital marketing! Based on real-world examples and case studies of other plumbing and HVAC contractors.

Get Book!
Josh Nelson Co-Founder & CEO

Why Plumbing & HVAC SEO?

600+ contractors served.
Marketing Resources & Guides